Taxes & fees · Guide
Section 7E struck down: how to claim back deemed income tax
By Pakizzle Editorial Team · Checked against official sources on
Published · Updated on · 6 min read

The short answer
Section 7E taxed 5% of the FBR value of certain property as deemed income at 20%, about 1% a year. The Federal Constitutional Court struck it down on 7 May 2026 and the Finance Act 2026 omitted it. If you paid it, revise your return under section 114(6), then apply for a refund under section 170.
Key facts
| Fact | Value | Source | As of |
|---|---|---|---|
| Section 7E treated a share of a property's fair market value as deemed income and taxed it, giving an effective annual levy. | 5% of value taxed at 20% (about 1%) | The Express Tribune: Tax refunds under Section 7E | |
| Section 7E's PKR 25 million limit applied to the combined fair market value of a person's capital assets, after excluding one asset and the other categories the | Combined value above PKR 25 million (not per property) | FBR: Income Tax Ordinance 2001 (amended up to 30.06.2022), section 7E(2)(a) and (g) | |
| Federal Constitutional Court ruling in Sher Muhammad Mughari v Federation of Pakistan. | Struck down as void ab initio on 7 May 2026 | The Express Tribune: Tax refunds under Section 7E | |
| Finance Act 2026 (effective 1 July 2026) on section 7E. | Section 7E omitted | Mettis Global: Commentary on Finance Act 2026-27 | |
| FBR instruction to field offices on return revisions filed because of the judgment. | Not to be rejected (23 Sep 2026) | The Express Tribune: Tax refunds under Section 7E | |
| Legal route to get the money back. | Revise under s.114(6), then refund under s.170 | The Express Tribune: Tax refunds under Section 7E | |
| Time the commissioner has to decide a section 170 refund application. | 60 days | The Express Tribune: Tax refunds under Section 7E |
If you held more than one property in Pakistan and their combined FBR value, after leaving out one property and the law's other exclusions, was over PKR 25 million, you may have paid tax under section 7E of the Income Tax Ordinance 2001: a yearly tax on income you never earned. That tax is gone, and money already paid can be claimed back. But the refund is not automatic. This guide explains what changed and the steps to recover what you paid.
What section 7E was
Section 7E came in through the Finance Act 2022, starting with tax year 2023. It treated 5% of the fair market value of specified property held by a resident as deemed income and taxed that amount at 20%. In effect, owners paid about 1% of the property's FBR value every year, whether or not it earned any rent. The PKR 25 million limit applied to the combined fair market value of the property a person held, not to each property. One property was left out, as were self-owned business premises, self-owned agricultural land, property whose rent was already taxed and some other categories, and the tax applied only if what remained came to more than PKR 25 million.
What the court decided
On 7 May 2026 the Federal Constitutional Court, in Sher Muhammad Mughari v Federation of Pakistan, declared section 7E unconstitutional and void ab initio, meaning void from the start. The court found that the levy was really a tax on the capital value of immovable property, which the federation cannot impose after the 18th Amendment, rather than a tax on income. It also annulled proceedings, assessments, demands and notices issued under section 7E.
The Finance Act 2026, in force from 1 July 2026, then omitted section 7E from the Ordinance.
What this means for you
- No new section 7E tax. You should not compute or pay it in any return.
- Pending notices fall away. Demands and notices issued under section 7E were annulled by the judgment.
- Money already paid must be claimed. The judgment does not change your return in IRIS or create a refund by itself. You must act.
How much you can claim
- You paid the full section 7E amount: the whole amount is excess tax and can be claimed.
- You paid 50% under a court's interim order: you can claim only the amount you actually deposited. The unpaid half simply stops being a liability.
- You paid separately after filing the return: you may need to correct both the return and the separate section 7E computation or payment record.
Steps to get a refund, in order
- Gather your records for each year: the original return, wealth statement, section 7E computation, payment receipt (CPR), any interim court order and FBR letters.
- Reconcile the amount computed with the amount actually paid. Unless these are linked correctly, IRIS may not show a refundable balance.
- Revise the return under section 114(6). Explain that the revision follows the constitutional judgment and keep it limited to section 7E. On 23 September 2026 FBR told its field offices not to reject such revision requests.
- Apply for a refund under section 170 once the revised return shows the excess. Any admitted excess is first set against other tax you owe, and the rest is refunded.
- Wait for the decision. The commissioner must decide in writing within 60 days, after giving you a hearing. If the order goes against you, or no decision comes in time, you can appeal under section 170(5).
Watch the time limit
A refund application must generally be filed within three years of the relevant assessment order or the date the tax was paid. Payments for the earliest years, tax year 2023 onwards, are the most at risk. Do not assume that revising a return restarts the clock. Act promptly and raise the time limit with your adviser.
Red flags
- Anyone promising a guaranteed refund for an upfront fee.
- Advice to revise every item in an old return at the same time. Keep the revision to section 7E.
- Claiming back more than you actually deposited.
How Pakizzle helps
Pakizzle's tax guides keep the other property taxes in one place: advance tax on buying (236K), advance tax on selling (236C) and capital gains tax on property. Each lists its sources and the date it was checked.
This is a guide, not tax advice. For your own refund, speak to a tax adviser or your FBR office before you file.
Questions
Section 7E ka refund kaise milega?
First revise the income tax return for each year you paid section 7E tax, under section 114(6), so the section 7E amount is removed. Then file a refund application under section 170. The commissioner must decide within 60 days after giving you a hearing.
Is section 7E tax still payable?
No. The Federal Constitutional Court struck section 7E down on 7 May 2026 as void from the start, and the Finance Act 2026 omitted it from 1 July 2026. Notices and demands issued under it were annulled.
Is the refund automatic?
No. The judgment does not change your return in IRIS or create a refund on its own. You have to revise the return and then apply for the refund.
I paid only 50% under an interim court order. What can I claim?
Only the amount you actually deposited. The unpaid 50% is not refundable; it simply stops being a valid liability once the section 7E computation is removed.
Is there a deadline for claiming the refund?
Generally a refund application must be made within three years of the relevant assessment order or the date the tax was paid. Older payments carry the most risk, so act promptly and take advice on the time limit.
Sources
- The Express Tribune: Tax refunds under Section 7E (9 Nov 2026)
- Profit: FCC declares section 7E deemed income tax unconstitutional (7 May 2026)
- Mettis Global: Commentary on Finance Act 2026-27 (1 Jul 2026)
- FBR: Income Tax Ordinance 2001, amended up to 30.06.2022 (section 7E, inserted by the Finance Act 2022)
Corrections
- : Corrected: the PKR 25 million limit in section 7E applied to the combined fair market value of a person's property after its exclusions (including one property), not to a single property. Earlier wording said it applied to a property worth over PKR 25 million.
Tools for this
Related guides
- Property tax calculator: advance tax, CVT and stamp duty Taxes & fees
Pakizzle's property tax calculator works out the taxes on a property transfer line by line, each with its legal source.
- Filer vs non-filer property tax rates in Pakistan Taxes & fees
Under the Finance Act 2026, a buyer on FBR's Active Taxpayers List pays 1.25% advance tax (section 236K) and a seller pays 2.75% (section…
- Declaring property in your FBR wealth statement Taxes & fees
If you are a resident individual filing an income tax return, Section 116(2) requires a wealth statement and wealth reconciliation with it.
- Gift deed (hiba) in Punjab: no stamp duty for close family Taxes & fees
Under Punjab's Stamp (Second Amendment) Ordinance 2026, gift deeds (hiba) between spouses, parents and children, grandparents and…